Learning science

Do concept maps help you study?

Drawing a concept map with your notes open feels like deep learning. The research says the magic is in drawing it with your notes closed.

By the Ace team · November 7, 2026 · 5 min read

Do concept maps help you study? — Ace blog

Short answer: concept maps help most when you draw them from memory. In Karpicke and Blunt's (2011) experiments, students who practised recalling a text remembered more a week later than students who built concept maps with the text in front of them. When concept maps were drawn from memory, they worked as well as written recall. So keep the maps, but close your notes first, then check and fill the gaps.

What is a concept map (and how is it different from a mind map)?

A concept map is a diagram of nodes and links: each node is a concept, and each link is labelled with the relationship ("causes", "is a type of", "is regulated by"). A mind map usually radiates from one central topic with branches and keywords, and the links are often unlabelled.

Both are popular on StudyTok and in revision guides because they look organised and show how a topic fits together. The question is whether making one helps you remember and use the material in an exam.

What happened when concept maps met retrieval practice

Karpicke and Blunt (2011), published in Science, ran two experiments with 200 students learning from science texts. One group studied by creating concept maps while they could see the text. Another group practised retrieval: they read the text, put it away and wrote down as much as they could recall, then read and recalled again.

Straight after studying, the groups did about the same. A week later, the retrieval group showed a 50% improvement in long-term retention over the concept-mapping group, on questions about specific facts and on inference questions. Most students predicted the opposite, which is a pattern seen again and again in learning research: the method that feels effective is not always the one that is.

Blunt and Karpicke (2014) then asked the obvious follow-up: what if you draw the concept map from memory? In two experiments, students practised retrieval either by writing paragraphs or by creating concept maps without the text. On a test a week later covering verbatim knowledge and inferences, both retrieval formats beat additional studying, and the two formats did not differ. The authors concluded that retrieval itself, not the act of writing, drives the benefit.

O'Day and Karpicke (2021) tested whether doing both helps: build a concept map with the text, then practise retrieval. Surprisingly, the combination produced no benefit over retrieval practice alone, even though students in the combined condition spent substantially more time with the material.

The debate since 2011

The story is not completely settled. Mayrhofer, Kuhbandner and Frischholz (2023) argued in Frontiers in Psychology that the original comparison was unfair, because the retrieval group had an extra memorisation phase that the concept-mapping group lacked. In their preregistered experiment with 230 participants, the retrieval advantage on verbatim questions disappeared once the concept-mapping group also memorised the material.

That critique is worth knowing, but it points the same way in practice: what helped was getting the material into memory and pulling it back out, not drawing boxes and arrows while copying. Nobody in this research found that concept mapping with your notes open is a better use of time than testing yourself.

How to use concept maps to revise, step by step

  1. Learn the topic first. Read the chapter or lecture once with full attention.
  2. Close everything. Notes, slides, tabs.
  3. Draw the map from memory. Put the main concepts down, connect them and label every link with the relationship. Labels matter: "photosynthesis → glucose" says little; "produces, using light energy" says what you know.
  4. Check against your notes in a different colour. Add what you missed and fix wrong links. The different colour shows you exactly where the gaps are.
  5. Redraw a few days later. A blank page again. Compare with your corrected version. This turns the map into spaced retrieval practice.
  6. Turn weak spots into questions. Any link you got wrong twice deserves a direct question you can test yourself on.

If this looks familiar, it is close to the blurting method, drawn as a diagram rather than written as a list. If an AI tool drew your map, our guide to making a mind map with AI shows how to use it as the answer key for a redraw.

When a concept map is the right tool

  • Topics built on relationships: body systems, causes of historical events, chemical pathways, legal tests with several elements.
  • Before an essay or long-answer question: mapping from memory shows you whether you can connect ideas, which is what those questions reward.
  • Less useful for isolated facts: vocabulary, dates and definitions are better served by direct questions. See how to memorise definitions.

Mapping from memory and answering direct questions work well together. Ace turns your own notes, slides or PDFs into practice questions written from that material only, including put-the-steps-in-order questions for processes, so you can test the links you mapped on the chapters you choose.

Frequently asked questions

Are mind maps good for revision?

They can be, if you draw them from memory and then check. Drawing them while copying from your notes is closer to rereading. Blunt and Karpicke (2014) found concept maps drawn from memory worked as well as written recall.

Is retrieval practice better than concept mapping?

Karpicke and Blunt (2011) found retrieval beat concept mapping with the text visible, by 50% on a test a week later. A 2023 study argued the original comparison was unfair. Either way, mapping from memory turns a concept map into retrieval practice.

Should I make a concept map and then test myself?

O'Day and Karpicke (2021) found that adding concept mapping before retrieval practice gave no extra benefit, despite taking more time. If time is short, skip the copied map and go straight to recall.

What is the difference between a concept map and a mind map?

A concept map links many concepts with labelled relationships; a mind map usually branches out from one central topic with keywords. Both can be drawn from memory as a recall exercise.

Sources

  1. Karpicke, J. D., & Blunt, J. R. (2011). Retrieval practice produces more learning than elaborative studying with concept mapping. Science, 331(6018), 772–775. Summary: ScienceDaily, 21 January 2011.
  2. Blunt, J. R., & Karpicke, J. D. (2014). Learning with retrieval-based concept mapping. Journal of Educational Psychology, 106(3), 849–858.
  3. O'Day, G. M., & Karpicke, J. D. (2021). Comparing and combining retrieval practice and concept mapping. Journal of Educational Psychology, 113(5), 986–997.
  4. Mayrhofer, R., Kuhbandner, C., & Frischholz, K. (2023). Re-examining the testing effect as a learning strategy: the advantage of retrieval practice over concept mapping as a methodological artifact. Frontiers in Psychology, 14.

Turn your notes into practice questions

Drop a PDF, slides or a YouTube lecture into Ace and get practice questions checked against your own material — then play them solo or against a friend.

Try Ace free