Short answer: within a few days of getting a test back, go through every lost mark and label why you lost it: didn't know it, misread the question, ran out of time, or knew it but slipped. Log the errors, find the right answer in your notes, and retest yourself on them a few days later and again a week after that. Research on learning from errors shows that mistakes followed by correction help learning, and confident mistakes are the ones most worth retesting.
Why mistakes are worth more than the grade
Janet Metcalfe's 2017 review in the Annual Review of Psychology pulls together the laboratory evidence: making errors and then getting corrective feedback is beneficial to learning. She also notes that feedback which analyses the reasoning behind a mistake is crucial, and argues that it can be worth letting students make and correct errors in low-stakes settings so they perform better when the stakes are high.
Mocks and class tests are exactly that low-stakes setting. The grade is a snapshot. The individual wrong answers are a map of what to do next. That is the thinking behind exam wrappers, short reflection sheets that teaching centres such as Carnegie Mellon's Eberly Center describe as handouts students complete when an exam is handed back, to identify strengths and weaknesses, judge their preparation and characterise their errors to find recurring patterns.
A fair warning on the evidence: when Soicher and Gurung (2017) tested exam wrappers in a single psychology course with 86 students, they found no improvement in exam scores, final grades or measured metacognition. Filling in a sheet is not magic. What matters is what you do with the mistakes afterwards, which is where the steps below focus.
Step 1: sort every mistake by cause
Go through the paper question by question and give each lost mark one label:
- Didn't know it. The content was missing or wrong in your head. Fix: relearn and retest.
- Half knew it. You recognised the topic but couldn't produce the detail. Fix: more retrieval practice, less rereading.
- Misread the question. You answered a different question from the one asked. Fix: practise underlining command words and constraints.
- Exam technique. Right idea, but missing the steps or keywords the mark scheme wanted. Fix: compare your answer with the mark scheme line by line.
- Time. You didn't reach it. Fix: timed practice sections.
- Slip. You knew it and made a careless error. Fix: a checking routine, not more content revision.
Count the labels. If most of your lost marks are "didn't know it", you have a content problem. If most are "misread" or "time", more hours on the textbook won't help; practice papers will. Our guide to using past papers covers timed practice.
Step 2: keep a mistake log
A mistake log, sometimes called an error log or mistake notebook, is one line per error. Keep it simple enough that you actually use it:
- The topic and question (or a short version of it).
- What you wrote.
- The correct answer, found in your own notes or textbook, with where it came from.
- The cause label from step 1.
- Dates you retested it, and whether you got it right.
Writing the correct answer yourself, from your notes, matters more than copying the teacher's red pen. It forces you to find and understand the source, which is the kind of corrective feedback Metcalfe describes as crucial.
Step 3: retest the confident mistakes
Some mistakes feel worse than others: the ones where you were sure. The research has good news and a catch. The hypercorrection effect is the finding that errors made with high confidence are more likely to be corrected after feedback than errors you were unsure about (Metcalfe, 2017).
The catch comes from Butler, Fazio and Marsh (2011). The hypercorrection effect was still there a week later, but error correction dropped over that week, and when people forgot the correct answer, high-confidence errors were more likely than low-confidence ones to come back. Your confident wrong answer is a strong memory; one correction may not be enough to beat it.
So mark the confident errors in your log with a star and retest them on purpose: once two or three days after the correction, and again a week or so later. If the old answer comes back, that's useful information, not failure. For a ready-made schedule, see the spaced repetition schedule.
Step 4: change how you revise
The point of an exam wrapper is the last question: what will you do differently next time? Answer it concretely.
- If most errors were content: plan short retrieval sessions on those topics over the next two weeks, rather than one long rereading session.
- If you lost marks on questions you thought you knew: start each session with a self-test before looking at notes. Our post on the illusion of competence explains why this catches false confidence.
- If time was the problem: do one timed section a week.
- If it was mostly slips: build a 5-minute checking routine into the end of practice papers.
Do this within a few days of getting the paper back, while you can still remember what you were thinking when you wrote each answer. For UK students coming out of mocks, our guide on revising for mocks covers the weeks before and after.
Retesting your mistakes is easier when the questions come from your own material. Ace turns your notes, slides or PDFs into practice questions written from that material only; you pick the chapters you got wrong, and under each answer Ace shows the sentence from your file that backs it, so every retest doubles as correction.
Checking every answer matters even when you are right but unsure; our guide to feedback after practice questions explains why.
Frequently asked questions
What is an exam wrapper?
A short reflection sheet you fill in when a marked exam comes back. It asks how you prepared, what kinds of mistakes you made and what you will change. Carnegie Mellon's Eberly Center is a well-known source of templates.
Do exam wrappers actually work?
The evidence is mixed. Soicher and Gurung (2017) found no improvement from using them in a single course. The research on learning from errors suggests the benefit comes from correcting and retesting mistakes, so treat the wrapper as the start of that work, not the whole of it.
How soon should I review a test after getting it back?
Within a few days, while you still remember your reasoning. Then retest the mistakes a few days later and again after about a week.
Why do I keep making the same mistake?
Confident wrong answers are strong memories. Butler, Fazio and Marsh (2011) found that when people forgot a correction, high-confidence errors were more likely to return, so these need more than one retest.
Sources
- Metcalfe, J. (2017). Learning from errors. Annual Review of Psychology, 68, 465–489.
- Butler, A. C., Fazio, L. K., & Marsh, E. J. (2011). The hypercorrection effect persists over a week, but high-confidence errors return. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 18(6), 1238–1244.
- Soicher, R. N., & Gurung, R. A. R. (2017). Do exam wrappers increase metacognition and performance? A single course intervention. Psychology Learning & Teaching, 16(1), 64–73.
- Eberly Center for Teaching Excellence. Exam wrappers. Carnegie Mellon University.



