Learning science

Desirable difficulties: why harder studying sticks

The study session that feels smooth is often the one you forget. Here is the research on why some struggle is worth keeping, and how to tell good struggle from bad.

By the Ace team · November 8, 2026 · 5 min read

Desirable difficulties: why harder studying sticks — Ace blog

Short answer: desirable difficulties are study conditions that make practice feel slower and harder but leave you remembering more later. The best known are testing yourself instead of rereading, spacing sessions apart, mixing topics, and varying how you practise. The psychologist Robert Bjork coined the term to separate how well you do while studying (performance) from what you keep (learning), and the two often point in opposite directions.

What are desirable difficulties?

The idea comes from Robert and Elizabeth Bjork at UCLA. Their starting point is a distinction that sounds obvious once you hear it: what you can see while studying is performance, how quickly and accurately you answer right now. What you actually want is learning, the lasting change that lets you answer in three weeks in an exam hall. As an APS Observer piece on their work puts it, quoting the Bjorks: "What we can observe is performance, but what we have to infer is learning."

Soderstrom and Bjork (2015) reviewed decades of research in motor and verbal learning and concluded that performance during practice is often an unreliable index of learning. Some conditions boost performance and do little for learning. Others depress performance during practice and improve learning. The second group, when the struggle is one you can overcome, are the desirable difficulties.

Why easy studying feels better but works worse

Rereading a chapter feels productive because everything looks familiar. Familiarity is a feeling of performance, and it is quickly mistaken for knowing. Two classic studies show how far that feeling can mislead.

Roediger and Karpicke (2006) had students study prose passages and then either reread them or take recall tests without feedback. On a test five minutes later, rereading won. On tests two days and a week later, the students who had tested themselves remembered substantially more, even though rereading had made students more confident in their memory.

Kornell and Bjork (2008) asked people to learn painters' styles from examples shown either grouped by artist or mixed with other artists. Mixing produced better recognition of new paintings, yet participants rated grouped study as more effective, even after their own test results had shown the opposite.

So the discomfort you feel when a question makes you stop and dig is not a sign the method is failing. Often it is the method working. If this sounds familiar, our post on the illusion of competence goes deeper on why fluent study fools us.

Four desirable difficulties to use this week

  1. Test instead of reread. Close the notes and answer questions, or write down everything you remember, then check. The effort of retrieving is what strengthens the memory. Dunlosky and colleagues (2013) rated practice testing as one of only two high-utility techniques out of the ten they reviewed.
  2. Space it out. Three short sessions on different days beat one long session the night before. The gap means you have partly forgotten, which makes retrieval harder and more useful. Distributed practice was the other high-utility technique in the Dunlosky review. Our spaced repetition schedule gives you dates to use.
  3. Mix topics. Instead of twenty questions on one chapter, mix questions from three. You have to work out which idea applies before you can answer, which is exactly what the exam asks. Kornell and Bjork's painting study is one example; our guide to interleaving has more.
  4. Vary the practice. Answer the same idea in different formats: a multiple-choice question, then a typed answer, then explaining it out loud. Variation is on the Bjorks' list of desirable difficulties because it stops memory leaning on one cue.

When difficulty is not desirable

"Make it harder" is not a licence to make studying miserable. The difficulty has to be one you can overcome with effort, and it has to make you engage with the content. Some difficulties fail both tests:

  • Material far beyond you. If you cannot answer anything, testing yourself just produces guessing. Learn the basics first, then test.
  • Distraction. Noise, a phone buzzing, or studying while half-watching something makes study harder without making you process the material more deeply.
  • Practice without feedback. A hard question you never check can leave a wrong answer in place. Always look up the right answer after you attempt.
  • Exhaustion. Fighting sleep is hard, not desirable. See how to study when tired.

A rough rule: if you are getting some answers right after a real effort, and checking the rest, the difficulty is probably the good kind. If you are getting almost nothing right, step back and relearn first.

How to start without hating it

  • Expect lower scores in practice. Decide in advance that a 60% quiz on a topic you studied last week is useful information, not a verdict.
  • Start with five questions. A short quiz at the start of each session is easier to commit to than a full mock.
  • Keep the wrong answers. They tell you exactly what to review next. Our guide on learning from exam mistakes shows how.
  • Judge by the delayed test. If you want to know whether a method works for you, test yourself a week later, not five minutes later.

The easiest desirable difficulty to build into every session is testing. Ace turns your own notes, slides and PDFs into practice questions written from that material only, in mixed formats such as multiple choice, put-the-steps-in-order and type-the-answer, and shows the sentence from your file that backs each answer, so every attempt comes with feedback. See how it works.

Frequently asked questions

Who came up with desirable difficulties?

Robert Bjork introduced the term in the 1990s, and he and Elizabeth Bjork have developed it since. Soderstrom and Bjork (2015) review the evidence for the learning-versus-performance distinction behind it.

What are examples of desirable difficulties?

The main ones are retrieval practice (testing yourself), spacing study sessions apart, interleaving or mixing topics, and varying the conditions of practice.

If studying feels hard, does that mean it is working?

Not automatically. It has to be a difficulty you can overcome and that makes you think about the content. Struggling with distraction, exhaustion or material far beyond you is just hard.

Why do I score worse when I mix topics?

Because you have to choose the right method before using it. Scores during practice usually drop, but later tests tend to improve, as Kornell and Bjork (2008) found with mixed versus grouped examples.

Sources

  1. Soderstrom, N. C., & Bjork, R. A. (2015). Learning versus performance: An integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 176–199.
  2. Hewer, M. (2016). Desirable difficulties. APS Observer, Association for Psychological Science.
  3. Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249–255.
  4. Kornell, N., & Bjork, R. A. (2008). Learning concepts and categories: Is spacing the "enemy of induction"? Psychological Science, 19(6), 585–592.
  5. Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., & Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58.

Turn your notes into practice questions

Drop a PDF, slides or a YouTube lecture into Ace and get practice questions checked against your own material — then play them solo or against a friend.

Try Ace free